Abbie Gardner Sharp Cabin
Arnolds Park, Dickinson County, Iowa
 |
Near the shore of West Okoboji Lake in northwestern Iowa stands a small log cabin.
There is nothing grand about it.
No towers rise above the trees. There are no enormous staircases, abandoned hospital wards, underground tunnels, or dark Victorian corridors.
Yet few places in Iowa carry a history as disturbing as the little cabin now known as the Abbie Gardner Sharp Cabin.
In March 1857, thirteen-year-old Abbie Gardner watched a violent frontier conflict destroy her family and change her life forever.
She was taken captive.
Decades later, she did something extraordinary.
She came back.
She purchased the cabin where the tragedy had occurred, preserved it, and spent the final decades of her life telling visitors what had happened there.
Today, stories of ghosts and unexplained experiences have become attached to the wider Spirit Lake tragedy and the places connected with it.
But separating documented history from later legend is particularly important here.
Because what actually happened at the Gardner Cabin requires no embellishment.
In the summer of 1856, Rowland and Frances Gardner brought their family to the Iowa Great Lakes region.
European-American settlement had arrived relatively late in this portion of northwestern Iowa.
The Gardner family reached the area in July, too late in the growing season to plant and harvest enough crops before winter. They brought provisions with them and began constructing a home near West Okoboji Lake.
By winter, one cabin had been completed.
A second had not.
The winter of 1856–1857 became exceptionally severe.
Settlers throughout the region struggled with isolation, brutal weather, and dwindling food supplies.
The Dakota people who had lived and hunted throughout the region faced an even larger crisis.
Years of American expansion and treaty negotiations had dramatically changed control of the land.
Inkpaduta, a Wahpekute Dakota leader, had been excluded from the 1851 treaty negotiations that transferred northwestern Iowa from Dakota control to the United States, and he did not recognize the resulting restrictions.
There was already blood between his band and white settlers.
Several years earlier, a settler named Henry Lott had murdered members of Inkpaduta's family.
Government authorities acknowledged Lott's responsibility but failed to apprehend him.
By the winter of 1857, Inkpaduta's small band was traveling through northwestern Iowa searching desperately for food.
They reached the Lake Okoboji settlements in early March.
Attempts to obtain provisions from settlers contributed to increasingly hostile encounters.
Then, on March 8, the tension exploded into violence.
Inkpaduta's band attacked the scattered settlements around Spirit Lake and Lake Okoboji.
The violence continued for several days.
According to the State Historical Society of Iowa, 33 settlers were killed.
Four women were taken captive.
One of them was thirteen-year-old Abbie Gardner.
At the Gardner homestead, nearly everyone occupying the cabin was killed.
Abbie survived.
She was taken away with the Dakota band as they traveled north.
The events became known for generations as the Spirit Lake Massacre, although modern historians increasingly place the violence within the broader context of Indigenous displacement, broken agreements, settler expansion, starvation, and earlier violence committed against Dakota people.
Understanding that context does not diminish the deaths of the Gardner family or the other settlers.
Nor does the killing of settlers erase what had happened to Dakota families.
Both histories belong to the story.
Abbie remained captive for nearly three months.
The four women taken during the attacks did not share the same fate.
Two died during the journey.
Another captive was eventually released.
Abbie was finally ransomed and released after approximately 84 days.
She returned to white society carrying memories that would follow her for the rest of her life.
She eventually married Cassville Sharp and became Abbie Gardner Sharp.
In 1885, she published an account of the attack and her captivity.
The book became widely read and went through numerous editions.
Like many nineteenth-century captivity narratives, Abbie's account reflected both her traumatic personal experience and the attitudes toward Native Americans common during the era in which she wrote it.
Her perspective continued developing later in life.
She became increasingly interested in Native American culture, collected Indigenous artifacts, and expressed a broader understanding of the people whose history had become inseparably connected with her own.
Then, in 1891, Abbie returned to the place where her childhood had ended.
She bought the Gardner Cabin.
By then, the structure had been altered and had deteriorated considerably.
Abbie restored the property and began welcoming visitors.
At first she reportedly told her story from a canvas tent beside the cabin.
As interest grew, the property developed into a small museum and tourist destination.
Visitors came to see the cabin.
They bought Abbie's book, postcards, and souvenirs.
And they listened while the woman who had survived the events of 1857 personally described what had happened there.
The site became one of Iowa's earliest tourist attractions.
In 1895, the State of Iowa erected a large monument near the cabin commemorating those killed during the Spirit Lake conflict.
Abbie continued preserving the site and telling its story until her death in 1921.
She was buried near her family.
The cabin remained.
Eventually, the State of Iowa acquired the property, and today the historic site is preserved by the State Historical Society of Iowa.
Portions of the original oak-log structure survive, and the cabin remains on the site where the Gardner family settled in 1856.
With such a history, ghost stories were almost inevitable.
Paranormal folklore surrounding the Spirit Lake and Okoboji region has included stories of strange figures, unexplained sounds, voices, and other unusual experiences associated with places connected to the 1857 violence.
The Gardner Cabin is frequently included in modern discussions of haunted Iowa.
But there is an important problem with many of those stories.
Specific paranormal claims about the cabin are considerably more difficult to document than the history itself.
Online retellings sometimes describe cries, apparitions, mysterious footsteps, or members of the Gardner family supposedly appearing around the property.
Reliable historical sources do not establish a long, well-documented record of those phenomena occurring inside the cabin.
There is also no solid historical basis for confidently identifying any alleged apparition as a particular member of the Gardner family.
That does not mean no visitor has ever experienced something unusual there.
It means the evidence stops before the story does.
And at this particular place, that distinction matters.
The Gardner Cabin does not need an invented ghost.
The building itself is a survivor.
Its logs stood while one family attempted to build a new life beside an Iowa lake.
They remained after violence destroyed that family.
They were still there when the surviving thirteen-year-old girl became a grown woman.
And they were there when she made the extraordinary decision to return to the place where some of the worst moments of her life had occurred.
Abbie did not allow the cabin to disappear.
Instead, she turned the place of her trauma into the place where she controlled how her story was told.
That may be the most remarkable part of the entire history.
Today, visitors can step inside the small cabin and stand only a few feet from walls connected directly to the events of 1857.
Nearby stand the memorial and the graves of members of the Gardner family.
The surrounding Iowa Great Lakes region has changed almost beyond recognition.
Arnolds Park became a resort community.
Homes, roads, businesses, boats, vacationers, and attractions replaced the isolated frontier landscape Abbie knew as a child.
Yet the cabin remains.
Whether anything supernatural remains with it is a question history cannot answer.
Perhaps visitors hear only an old building settling.
Perhaps the knowledge of what happened there makes ordinary sounds seem different.
Perhaps some experiences simply remain unexplained.
But there is something undeniably haunting about the little cabin beside the lake.
Not because we can prove that ghosts walk through it.
But because a thirteen-year-old girl survived something terrible there, carried it with her into adulthood, and eventually returned to face the place itself.
She bought it.
She preserved it.
And for thirty years, Abbie Gardner Sharp sat beside the cabin and made certain that people remembered.
More than a century after her death, they still do.
Visitor Information:
Abbie Gardner Sharp Cabin Historic Site
74 Monument Drive
Arnolds Park, Iowa 51331
Phone: (712) 336-6352
Website: https://history.iowa.gov/visit/historic-sites/abbie-gardner-sharp-cabin
The Abbie Gardner Sharp Cabin is a State Historical Society of Iowa historic site and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. The cabin is generally open seasonally from Memorial Day through Labor Day, with free admission. Hours, tours, and access can change, so visitors should check current information before traveling. The nearby graves and memorial commemorate real people who died during the 1857 conflict and should be treated respectfully.
